Debating the iPhone

Why I want a 3G iPhone:

  • 3G
  • Syncs well with my laptop
  • iPhone + Truck = hands free music and phone (music pause on incoming call)
  • 16GB + in my pocket
  • etc

Why I don’t want an iPhone:

  • G4 Powerbook
  • iMac
  • MacBook Pro
  • 2 iPods
  • Airport Extreme
  • Apple TV
  • + accessories

I am a little hesitant to walk headlong into increased vendor dependance. Will that stop me? Doubtful.

4 Comments

  1. Posted May 18, 2008 at 11:32 am | Permalink

    Yeah, but do any of those devices work well together?

  2. Posted May 18, 2008 at 1:16 pm | Permalink

    re: “I am a little hesitant to walk headlong into increased vendor dependance.”

    Jackson, I think you jumped off that cliff about three devices ago. Sidenote: You’re about to hit the limit on the number of authorized devices (5) that will play something you purchase via the iTunes Store — another reason for using something that is less dependent on the Apple-o-sphere — and to extract DRM from iTunes Store purchases.

    -Rex (who is hopelessly dependent on Steve Jobs)

  3. Posted May 18, 2008 at 10:51 pm | Permalink

    Yeah Chuck, the devices do work well together, but they also create lock-in. I am excited to see the new blackberry supporting iTunes sync (not that I am going to get the new blackberry, but…)

    Rex, that ship has indeed sailed. This is not my beautiful house. How did I get here?

    With the demise of AllOfMp3.com I have been buying more music from iTunes, but my movies are mostly coming from ripping DVD rentals. Redbox is my gateway to content piracy.

  4. Posted May 19, 2008 at 10:54 pm | Permalink

    As a Mac user since 1985, I’ve long since given up worrying about lock-in to Apple products. Even through the dark 90’s, Apple still made the best gear available.

    Besides, I’m not sure what you mean by lock-in or vendor dependence with regard to having a lot of Apple products. Doesn’t your Airport Extreme work well with non-Apple devices? Can’t you still swap it out for a Linksys piece of crap if you were so inclined? As long as Apple has some credible competition, open source or otherwise, I don’t think it’s a worthwhile worry.

    @Rex — the 5 device limit applies only to computers, not iPods, iPhones or AppleTVs, so he’s only 60% there. ;-) Buying Amazon MP3s is a lot easier than stripping Apple’s DRM. Better would be the labels just giving up altogether, as we all know they will eventually.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*